Appeal Number:
OPA-PA-12-007
Appeal Relative to:
Request for Proposal No. RFP/DOA-014-11 Point of Sale
Appellant:
Data Management Resources, LLC
Purchasing Agency:
- General Services Agency
Appeal Received:
Monday, April 2, 2012 - 1:45pm
Appeal Status:
- Dismissed
Type of Appeal:
- Decision on Protest
Procurement Record Due:
Tuesday, April 10, 2012 - 5:00pm
Procurement Record Filed:
Saturday, March 10, 2012 - 9:15am
Agency Report Due:
Tuesday, April 17, 2012 - 5:00pm
Agency Report Filed:
Tuesday, April 17, 2012 - 3:45pm
Comments On Agency Report Due:
Friday, April 27, 2012 - 5:00pm
Comments on Agency Report Filed:
Friday, May 4, 2012 - 3:30pm
Rebuttal from Agency Due:
Tuesday, May 15, 2012 - 5:00pm
Rebuttal from Agency Filed:
Tuesday, May 15, 2012 - 5:00pm
Pre-Hearing:
Thursday, May 17, 2012 - 2:00pm
Tentative Hearing Date:
Tuesday, December 18, 2012 - 9:00am
Disposition Filed:
Thursday, December 27, 2012 - 8:30am
Disposition:
Notice of Withdrawal of Procurement Appeal
Remarks:
Update: A Notice of Withdrawal of Procurement Appeal was filed on December 27, 2012.
*MP3's are displayed through audio players. Other audio file types are displayed as links. You may need a player installed in your device to play certain audio files for non-MP3's.
File Name
Access/Download File
File Size / File Type
Notice of Appeal
Download OPA-PA-12-007_Notice_of_Appeal.pdf (1.15 MB) - PDF Order of Dismissal
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Order of Dismissal 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Order_of_Dismissal.pdf (111.14 KB) Download 12-007_Order_of_Dismissal.pdf (111.14 KB) - PDF Notice of Receipt of Appeal
https://mail.opaguam.org notice of receipt of appeal.pdf
Download Notice_of_Receipt_of_Appeal.pdf (9.98 MB) Download Notice_of_Receipt_of_Appeal.pdf (9.98 MB) - PDF Submission of Procurement Record - TOC only - large file - contact Rachel Field @ 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Download OPA-PA-12-007_Procurement_Record_TOC.pdf (73.23 KB) - PDF Agency Report - TOC only - large file - contact Rachel Field @ 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Download OPA-PA-12-007_Agency_Report_TOC.pdf (50.7 KB) - PDF Entry of Appearance - Office of Attorney General/GSA Legal Counsel
Download OPA-PA-12-007_Entry_of_Appearance.pdf (77.77 KB) - PDF Appellant's Comments on Agency Report
Download 12-007_Appellants_Comments_to_Agency_Report.pdf (459.67 KB) - PDF Appellant's Motion for Order to Disclose Procurement Record
Notice of Status Hearing
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Notice of Status Hearing 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Notice_of_Status_Hearing.pdf (83.84 KB) Download 12-007_Notice_of_Status_Hearing.pdf (83.84 KB) - PDF Hearing Request
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Hearing Request 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Hearing_Request.pdf (68.98 KB) Download 12-007_Hearing_Request.pdf (68.98 KB) - PDF Notice of Rescheduled Status Hearing
Download 12-007_Notice_of_Rescheduled_Status_Hearing.pdf (120.76 KB) - PDF Entry of Appearance - Governor
Download 12-007_Entry_of_Appearance_Governor.pdf (43.64 KB) - PDF Motion for Extension of Time to File Agency Rebuttal to Comments
Download 12-007_Motion_for_Extension_to_File_Agency_Rebuttal.pdf (150.78 KB) - PDF Rebuttal to Appellant's Comments on Agency Report
Download 12-007_Rebuttal_to_Appellant's_Comments_on_Agency_Report.pdf (897.14 KB) - PDF Supporting Rebuttal to Appellant's Comments
Download 12-007_Support_for_Rebuttal_to_Appellant's_Comments.pdf (115.2 KB) - PDF Order After Hearing
Download OPA-PA-12-007_Order_After_Hearing.pdf (73.48 KB) - PDF First Augmentation of Procurement Record Transmittal - large file - contact Rachel Field @ 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Download 12-007_Augmentation_of_Procurement_Record.pdf (185.14 KB) - PDF Errata to First Augmentation of Procurement Record Transmittal
Download DOC028.pdf (80.45 KB) - PDF Second Augmentation of Procurement Record Transmittal - large file - contact Rachel Field @ 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Download 12-007_Second_Augmentation_of_Procurement_Record.pdf (159.21 KB) - PDF Notice of Motion and Verified Motion to Dismiss Appeal
Notice of Hearing Appellants Motion for Discovery
Appellants Motion for Discovery
Download 12-007_Appellants_Motion_for_Discovery.pdf (327.62 KB) - PDF Appellants Verified Application for Subpoenas
Download 12-007_Appellants_Verified_Application_for_Subpoenas.pdf (130.13 KB) - PDF Declaration of Jacqueline Terlaje in Support of Appellants Motion
Appellant's Opposition and Request to Strike
Download 12-007_Appellant's_Opposition_and_Request_to_Strike.pdf (571.71 KB) - PDF Affidavit of Richard C. Taitano
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Affidavit of Richard Taitano 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Affidavit_of_Richard_Taitano.pdf (665.31 KB) Download 12-007_Affidavit_of_Richard_Taitano.pdf (665.31 KB) - PDF Declaration of Bryan J. Cruz
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Declaration of Bryan Cruz 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Bryan_Cruz.pdf (178.19 KB) Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Bryan_Cruz.pdf (178.19 KB) - PDF Stipulation for Enlargement of Time
Download 12-007_Stipulation_for_Enlargement_of_Time.pdf (74.68 KB) - PDF Declaration of Thomas W. Ashe Re Fiber Optic Cable
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Thomas_W._Ashe_Re_Fiber_Optic_Cable.pdf (101.88 KB) - PDF Declaration of Roberta Joyce Reyes Castro
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Roberta_Castro.pdf (3.21 MB) - PDF Declaration of Ed Camacho Cruz
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Ed_Camacho_Cruz.pdf (102.98 KB) - PDF Jurisdiction of the Office of Public Accountability
Download 12-007_Jurisdiction_of_the_Office_of_Public_Accountability.pdf (495.74 KB) - PDF Appellant's Memo in Reply to Support of Jurisdiction
Download 12-007_Appellant's_Memo_in_Reply_to_Support_of_Jurisdiction.pdf (482.17 KB) - PDF Declaration of Benita Manglona (07.02.12)
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Benita_Manglona_(07.02.12).pdf (96.86 KB) - PDF Declaration of Rosita Fejeran
Download OPA-PA-12-007_Declaration_of_Rosita_Fejeran.pdf (89.04 KB) - PDF Declaration of Benita Manglona (07.06.12)
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Benita_Manglona.pdf (279.19 KB) - PDF Third Augmentation of Procurement Record Transmittal
Download 12-007_Third_Augmentation_of_Procurement_Record_Transmittal.pdf (199.85 KB) - PDF Notice of Deposition
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Notice of Deposition 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Notice_of_Deposition.pdf (558.4 KB) Download 12-007_Notice_of_Deposition.pdf (558.4 KB) - PDF Decision and Order Re OPA Authority to Hear New Issues
Download 12-007_Decision_and_Order_Re_OPA_Authority.pdf (280.58 KB) - PDF Notice of Cancellation of Deposition - Bernadette F. Artero
Notice of Deposition - Kathy Kagigi
Download 12-007_Notice_of_Deposition_Kathy_Kagigi.pdf (80.03 KB) - PDF Declaration of Benjamin M. Abrams Amending Motion
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Benjamin_Abrams_Amending_Motion.pdf (137.43 KB) - PDF Scheduling Order for Hearing Re Appellant's Appeal
Download PA-12-007_Scheduling_Order_for_Hearing.pdf (128.83 KB) - PDF Stipulation and Request to Enlarge Time for Hearing
Notice of Rescheduled Hearing Re Appellant's Appeal
Revised Scheduling Order for Hearing Re Appellant's Appeal
Download 12-007_Revised_Scheduling_Order_for_Hearing.pdf (116.66 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Benita Manglona
Download 12-007_Subpoena.pdf (83.17 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Benigno Camacho
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Benigno Camacho 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Benigno_Camacho.pdf (239.36 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Benigno_Camacho.pdf (239.36 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Ed C. Cruz
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Ed C. Cruz 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Ed_C._Cruz.pdf (233.59 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Ed_C._Cruz.pdf (233.59 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Thomas Ashe
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Thomas Ashe 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Thomas_Ashe.pdf (250.17 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Thomas_Ashe.pdf (250.17 KB) - PDF Subpoena Duces Tecum - R. S. Taitano
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Duces_Tecum_R._S._Taitano.pdf (237.58 KB) - PDF Subpoena Duces Tecum - R. C. Taitano
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Duces_Tecum_R._C._Taitano.pdf (239.37 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Declaration of Service 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service.pdf (73.46 KB) Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service.pdf (73.46 KB) - PDF Appellant's Motion for Protective Order
Download 12-007_Appellant's_Motion_for_Protective.pdf (694.89 KB) - PDF Application for Subpoena
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Application for Subpoena 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Application_for_Subpoena.pdf (248.07 KB) Download 12-007_Application_for_Subpoena.pdf (248.07 KB) - PDF Application for Duces Tecum
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Application for Duces Tecum 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Application_for_Duces_Tecum.pdf (128.69 KB) Download 12-007_Application_for_Duces_Tecum.pdf (128.69 KB) - PDF AG's Application for Subpoenae
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 AG Application for Subpoenae 0.pdf
Download 12-007_AG_Application_for_Subpoenae.pdf (103.51 KB) Download 12-007_AG_Application_for_Subpoenae.pdf (103.51 KB) - PDF AG's Hearing Brief
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 AG Hearing Brief 0.pdf
Download 12-007_AG_Hearing_Brief.pdf (170.44 KB) Download 12-007_AG_Hearing_Brief.pdf (170.44 KB) - PDF AG's Witness and Exhibits List
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 AG Witness Exhibits List 0.pdf
Download 12-007_AG_Witness_Exhibits_List.pdf (94.93 KB) Download 12-007_AG_Witness_Exhibits_List.pdf (94.93 KB) - PDF Appellant's Verified Application for Subpoenas
Appellant's Witness List
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Appellants Witness List 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Appellants_Witness_List.pdf (101.68 KB) Download 12-007_Appellants_Witness_List.pdf (101.68 KB) - PDF Appellant's Hearing Brief
Download 12-007_Appellants_Hearing_Brief.pdf (1.06 MB) - PDF Appellant's Exhibit List - TOC only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Appellants Exhibit List 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Appellants_Exhibit_List.pdf (135.19 KB) Download 12-007_Appellants_Exhibit_List.pdf (135.19 KB) - PDF Appellant’s Submission of Written Testimony - Benigno Camacho - Transmittal only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Appellant’s Submission of Written Testimony - Elaine Fejarang - Transmittal only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Appellant’s Submission of Written Testimony - Katherine Kakigi - Transmittal only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Appellant’s Submission of Written Testimony - Rosita Fejeran - Transmittal only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Appellant’s Submission of Written Testimony - Benita Manglona - Transmittal only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Appellant’s Submission of Written Testimony - Claudia Acfalle - Transmittal only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Appellant’s Submission of Written Testimony - Thomas W. Ashe - Transmittal only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Supplemental Exhibit List
Download 12-007_Supplemental_Exhibit_List.pdf (1.83 MB) - PDF Affidavit of Appellant's Motion for Disqualification of Public Auditor
Appellant's Motion for Disqualification of Public Auditor
Opposition to Disqualification
Download 12-007_Opposition_to_Disqualification.pdf (146.15 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to Law Office of J. Terlaje
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_Office_of_JTerlaje.pdf (53.94 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to R. C. Taitano
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_RC_Taitano.pdf (50.4 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to E. Villaverde
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_E_Villaverde.pdf (50.17 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to B. Artero
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_B_Artero.pdf (259.13 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to B. Camacho
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_B_Camacho.pdf (272.32 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to R. Fejeran
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_R_Fejeran.pdf (260.54 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to Benita Manglona
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_B_Manglona.pdf (252.63 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to J. Manibusan
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_J_Manibusan.pdf (263.82 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to K. Borja
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_K_Borja.pdf (257.79 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to Kathy Kakigi
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_K_Kakigi.pdf (264.34 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to C. Acfalle
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_C_Acfalle.pdf (263.36 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to M. Leon Guerrero
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_M_LeonGuerrero.pdf (264.78 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to E. Lujan
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_to_E_Lujan.pdf (268.36 KB) - PDF Appellant's Reply to Opposition to Motion for Disqualification of Public Auditor
Download 12-007_Appellants_Reply_to_Opposition.pdf (182.72 KB) - PDF Decision Order Disqualification of Public Auditor
Download 12-007_Decision_Order_Disqualification_of_PublicAuditor.pdf (280.06 KB) - PDF Subpoena Thomas Ashe
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Thomas Ashe 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Thomas_Ashe.pdf (250.17 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Thomas_Ashe.pdf (250.17 KB) - PDF Subpoena Dawn Erwin
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Dawn Erwin 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Dawn_Erwin.pdf (217.84 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Dawn_Erwin.pdf (217.84 KB) - PDF Subpoena Josephine Mariano
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Josephine_Mariano.pdf (230.7 KB) - PDF Subpoena Patricia Salas
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Patricia Salas 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Patricia_Salas.pdf (221.19 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Patricia_Salas.pdf (221.19 KB) - PDF Subpoena Benita Manglona
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Benita Manglona 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Benita_Manglona.pdf (228.81 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Benita_Manglona.pdf (228.81 KB) - PDF Subpoena Benigo Camacho
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Benigo Camacho 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Benigo_Camacho.pdf (219.09 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Benigo_Camacho.pdf (219.09 KB) - PDF Subpoena Jon Littlepage
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Jon Littlepage 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Jon_Littlepage.pdf (220.3 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Jon_Littlepage.pdf (220.3 KB) - PDF Declaration of Non-Service
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Non-Service.pdf (87.59 KB) - PDF Subpoena Claudia Acfalle
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena C Acfalle 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_C_Acfalle.pdf (261.89 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_C_Acfalle.pdf (261.89 KB) - PDF Certification of Procurement Record
Download 12-007_Certification_of_Procurement_Record.pdf (53.69 KB) - PDF Declaration of Bryan Cruz
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Declaration Bryan J Cruz 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Declaration_Bryan_J_Cruz.pdf (99.16 KB) Download 12-007_Declaration_Bryan_J_Cruz.pdf (99.16 KB) - PDF Subpoena Duces Tecum
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Subpoena Duces Tecum 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Subpoena_Duces_Tecum.pdf (236.7 KB) Download 12-007_Subpoena_Duces_Tecum.pdf (236.7 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service to Richard S. Taitano
Download 12-007_Declaration_of_Service_Richard_Taitano.pdf (56.12 KB) - PDF Application for Subpoena Duces Tecum
Download 12-007_App_for_Subpoena_Duces_Tecum.pdf (53.38 KB) - PDF Declaration of Service - Thomas W. Ashe
Download 12-007_Declaration_Thomas_W._Ashe_.pdf (68.61 KB) - PDF Special Appearance by Office of Attorney General
Download 12-013_Special_Appearance_by_Office_of_Attorney_General.pdf (59.38 KB) - PDF Memo Supporting Special Entry of Appearance by Office of Attorney General
Substitute of Counsel
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Substitute of Counsel 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Substitute_of_Counsel.pdf (60.22 KB) Download 12-007_Substitute_of_Counsel.pdf (60.22 KB) - PDF Appellant's Opposition to the Special Appearance of the Office of the Attorney General of Guam
Order Dismissal by Stipulation
Download 12-007_Order_Dismissal_by_Stipulation.pdf (1.18 MB) - PDF Notice RE 18 Nov 2012 Hearing
Download 12-007_Notice_RE_Nov_2012_Hearing.pdf (81.72 KB) - PDF Notice Re 18 December 2012 Hearing
Download 12-007_Notice_Re_December_2012_Hearing.pdf (84.15 KB) - PDF Supplemental Memorandum RE Attorney General - TOC only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
Download 12-007_Supplemental_Memorandum_RE_Attorney_General.pdf (554.1 KB) - PDF Entry of Appearance - Governor of Guam
Download 12-007_Entry_of_Appearance_Governor.pdf (43.64 KB) - PDF Second Declaration of Ed Camacho Cruz
Download 12-007_Second_Declaration_of_Ed_Camacho_Cruz_.pdf (87.29 KB) - PDF Opposition to Special Entry
Download 12-007_Opposition_to_Special_Entry.pdf (1.19 MB) - PDF Order After Hearing (12.19.12)
Download 12-007_Order_After_Hearing(12.19.12).pdf (134.3 KB) - PDF Notice of Withdrawal of Procurement Appeal
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-007 Withdrawal of Appeal 0.pdf
Download 12-007_Withdrawal_of_Appeal.pdf (85.85 KB) Download 12-007_Withdrawal_of_Appeal.pdf (85.85 KB) - PDF 
