NEW! OPA APP
Close (X)
Close (X)
Close (X)
Close (X)
Close (X)

Subscribe to OPA's Emailing List

Enter your email address to receive updates from OPA.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

We care about your privacy and would never share your email address. You can unsubscribe by contacting OPA.

 
Close (X)

Use Advanced Search...

Narrow your search through OPA's vast database of Audits, Filed Appeals, and more.
Performance Audits

> Search 2013 & prior here
Financial Audits

> Search 2013 & prior here
Procurement Appeals

Performance Audits

Financial Audits

Procurement Appeals

E.g., 01/13/2026

Tokio Marine Pacific Insurance (Tokio Marine) and Calvos Insurance Underwriters (CIU) vs. Department of Administration (DOA)

Appeal Number: 
OPA-PA-12-013
Appeal Relative to: 
DOA/HRD RFP-GHI-13-001 FY 2013 Health Insurance Program
Appellant: 
Tokio Marine Pacific Insurance (Tokio Marine) and Calvos Insurance Underwriters (CIU)

Purchasing Agency:

  • Department of Administration
Appeal Received: 
Wednesday, September 19, 2012 - 4:45pm

Appeal Status:

  • Dismissed

Type of Appeal:

  • Decision on Protest
Procurement Record Due: 
Tuesday, October 9, 2012 - 5:00pm
Procurement Record Filed: 
Tuesday, October 9, 2012 - 4:15pm
Agency Report Due: 
Tuesday, October 16, 2012 - 5:00pm
Agency Report Filed: 
Tuesday, October 16, 2012 - 5:00pm
Comments On Agency Report Due: 
Friday, November 9, 2012 - 5:00pm
Comments on Agency Report Filed: 
Friday, November 9, 2012 - 3:30pm
Rebuttal from Agency Due: 
Monday, November 19, 2012 - 5:00pm
Pre-Hearing: 
Tuesday, November 20, 2012 - 2:00pm
Tentative Hearing Date: 
Tuesday, March 5, 2013 - 9:00am
Disposition Filed: 
Monday, February 25, 2013 - 2:00pm
Disposition: 
Stipulation and Order for Dismissal of Procurement Appeal
*MP3's are displayed through audio players. Other audio file types are displayed as links. You may need a player installed in your device to play certain audio files for non-MP3's.
File Name
Access/Download File
File Size / File Type
Notice of Appeal
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Notice of Appeal 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_of_Appeal.pdf (30.88 MB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_of_Appeal.pdf (30.88 MB) - PDF
Approved Stipulation and Order for Dismissal
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Approved Stipulation Order for Dismissal 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Approved_Stipulation_Order_for_Dismissal.pdf (243.03 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Approved_Stipulation_Order_for_Dismissal.pdf (243.03 KB) - PDF
Notice of Receipt of Appeal
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Notice of Receipt of Appeal 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_of_Receipt_of_Appeal.pdf (382.89 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_of_Receipt_of_Appeal.pdf (382.89 KB) - PDF
Pre-Hearing Audio Record (11.20.12)
Audio Link
(44.18 MB ) - MP3
Entry of Appearance
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Entry of Appearance 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Entry_of_Appearance.pdf (68.67 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Entry_of_Appearance.pdf (68.67 KB) - PDF
Notice of Appeal to Interested Parties
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Notice of Appeal to Interested Parties 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_of_Appeal_to_Interested_Parties.pdf (84.6 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_of_Appeal_to_Interested_Parties.pdf (84.6 KB) - PDF
Notice to Public Auditor of Interested Parties
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Notice to Public Auditor of Interested Parties 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_to_Public_Auditor_of_Interested_Parties.pdf (80.09 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_to_Public_Auditor_of_Interested_Parties.pdf (80.09 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service.pdf (73.28 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service.pdf (73.28 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Mailing
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Mailing 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Mailing.pdf (77.22 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Mailing.pdf (77.22 KB) - PDF
Stipulation for Extension of Dates to File Procurement Record and Agency Record
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Stipulation for Extension to file Procurement Agency Record 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Stipulation_for_Extension_to_file_Procurement_Agency_Record.pdf (145.96 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Stipulation_for_Extension_to_file_Procurement_Agency_Record.pdf (145.96 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - Vanessa R. Santos
https://mail.opaguam.org OPA-PA-12-013 Declaration of Service 2 0.pdf
PDF icon Download OPA-PA-12-013_Declaration_of_Service__2.pdf (83.67 KB)
PDF icon Download OPA-PA-12-013_Declaration_of_Service__2.pdf (83.67 KB) - PDF
Entry of Appearance and Request for Notice - Mair, Mair, Spade & Thompson
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Entry of appearance 2 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Entry_of_appearance_2.pdf (57.16 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Entry_of_appearance_2.pdf (57.16 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - Catrina Campana
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service Catrina Campana 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_Catrina_Campana.pdf (93.87 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_Catrina_Campana.pdf (93.87 KB) - PDF
Entry of Appearance and Request for Notice - Cabot Mantanona
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Entry of Appearance Cabot Mantanona 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Entry_of_Appearance_Cabot_Mantanona.pdf (55.05 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Entry_of_Appearance_Cabot_Mantanona.pdf (55.05 KB) - PDF
Notice Entry of Appearance - Calvo, Fisher, Jacob
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Entry of Appearance Calvo Fisher Jacob 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Entry_of_Appearance_Calvo_Fisher_Jacob.pdf (63.61 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Entry_of_Appearance_Calvo_Fisher_Jacob.pdf (63.61 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - Janalynn Cruz Damian
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service Janalynn Cruz Damian 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_Janalynn_Cruz_Damian.pdf (98.58 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_Janalynn_Cruz_Damian.pdf (98.58 KB) - PDF
Procurement Record - TOC only - Large file - contact Rachel Field @ 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Procurement Record 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Procurement_Record.pdf (412.11 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Procurement_Record.pdf (412.11 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - Alisa Munoz
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service Alisa Munoz 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_Alisa_Munoz.pdf (71.92 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_Alisa_Munoz.pdf (71.92 KB) - PDF
Request for Hearing
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Request for Hearing 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Request_for_Hearing.pdf (52.7 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Request_for_Hearing.pdf (52.7 KB) - PDF
Agency Report - TOC only - Large file - Contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Agency Report 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Agency_Report.pdf (25.83 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Agency_Report.pdf (25.83 KB) - PDF
Notice of Appointment of Hearing Officer
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Notice Appointment of Hearing Officer 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_Appointment_of_Hearing_Officer.pdf (103.18 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_Appointment_of_Hearing_Officer.pdf (103.18 KB) - PDF
Errata to Agency Report - Transmittal only - Large file - contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Errata to Agency Report 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Errata_to_Agency_Report.pdf (64.88 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Errata_to_Agency_Report.pdf (64.88 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - A. Munoz
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service AMunoz 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_AMunoz.pdf (67.67 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_AMunoz.pdf (67.67 KB) - PDF
Detailed Index of Confidential Procurement Record
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Detailed Index of Confidential Procurement Record 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Detailed_Index_of_Confidential_Procurement_Record.pdf (440.11 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Detailed_Index_of_Confidential_Procurement_Record.pdf (440.11 KB) - PDF
Amendment to Procurement Record - Transmittal only - Large file - contact Rachel Field at 475-0390 ext. 206 to view
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Amendment to Procurement Record 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Amendment_to_Procurement_Record.pdf (51.77 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Amendment_to_Procurement_Record.pdf (51.77 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - A.M.
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service AM 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_AM.pdf (69.12 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_AM.pdf (69.12 KB) - PDF
Amended Detailed Index of Confidential Procurement Records
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Amended Detailed Index 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Amended_Detailed_Index.pdf (715.36 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Amended_Detailed_Index.pdf (715.36 KB) - PDF
Stipulation Order Extension Comments - JacobCalvoFisher
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Stipulation Order Extension Comments JacobCalvoFIsher 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Stipulation_Order_Extension_Comments_JacobCalvoFIsher.pdf (147.79 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Stipulation_Order_Extension_Comments_JacobCalvoFIsher.pdf (147.79 KB) - PDF
Stipulation Order Extension Comments - MairSpadeThompson
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Stipulation Order Extension Comments MairSpadeThompson 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Stipulation_Order_Extension_Comments_MairSpadeThompson.pdf (135.11 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Stipulation_Order_Extension_Comments_MairSpadeThompson.pdf (135.11 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - Munoz
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service - Munoz 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_-_Munoz.pdf (71.19 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_-_Munoz.pdf (71.19 KB) - PDF
Appellant's Comments on Agency Report
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Appellants Comments on Agency Report 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Appellants_Comments_on_Agency_Report.pdf (874.48 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Appellants_Comments_on_Agency_Report.pdf (874.48 KB) - PDF
TakeCare's Comments on Agency Report
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 TakeCares Comments on Agency Report 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_TakeCares_Comments_on_Agency_Report.pdf (1.86 MB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_TakeCares_Comments_on_Agency_Report.pdf (1.86 MB) - PDF
Declaration of Service C. Graniel
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service C Graniel 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_C_Graniel.pdf (88.99 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_C_Graniel.pdf (88.99 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service J. Damian
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service J Damian 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_J_Damian.pdf (88.86 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_J_Damian.pdf (88.86 KB) - PDF
Notice of Pre-Hearing
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Notice of Pre-Hearing 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_of_Pre-Hearing.pdf (79.09 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Notice_of_Pre-Hearing.pdf (79.09 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - Mair
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service Mair 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_Mair.pdf (102.76 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_Mair.pdf (102.76 KB) - PDF
Request for Telephonic Appearance
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Request for Telephonic Appearance 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Request_for_Telephonic_Appearance.pdf (69.71 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Request_for_Telephonic_Appearance.pdf (69.71 KB) - PDF
Rebuttal to Comments on Agency Report
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Rebuttal to Comments on Agency Re 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Rebuttal_to_Comments_on_Agency_Re.pdf (466.94 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Rebuttal_to_Comments_on_Agency_Re.pdf (466.94 KB) - PDF
Scheduling Order
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Scheduling Order 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Scheduling_Order.pdf (242.3 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Scheduling_Order.pdf (242.3 KB) - PDF
Joint Scheduling Order
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Joint Scheduling Order 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Joint_Scheduling_Order.pdf (218.44 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Joint_Scheduling_Order.pdf (218.44 KB) - PDF
TakeCare Witness List
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 TakeCare Witness List 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_TakeCare_Witness_List.pdf (97.5 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_TakeCare_Witness_List.pdf (97.5 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - V. Santos
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service VSantos 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_VSantos.pdf (104.63 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_VSantos.pdf (104.63 KB) - PDF
Appellant's Witness List
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Appellants Witness List 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Appellants_Witness_List.pdf (134.38 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Appellants_Witness_List.pdf (134.38 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - J. Damian
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service JDamian 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_JDamian.pdf (89.33 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_JDamian.pdf (89.33 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - V. Santos 2
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service VSantos 2 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_VSantos_2.pdf (96.56 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_VSantos_2.pdf (96.56 KB) - PDF
Motion to Dismiss Procurement Appeal
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Motion to Dismiss Appeal 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Motion_to_Dismiss_Appeal.pdf (646.46 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Motion_to_Dismiss_Appeal.pdf (646.46 KB) - PDF
Appellant’s Opposition to Motion to Dismiss Procurement Appeal
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Appellants Opposition to Dismiss 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Appellants_Opposition_to_Dismiss.pdf (581.95 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Appellants_Opposition_to_Dismiss.pdf (581.95 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - J. Damian 2
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service JDamian 12.28.12 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_JDamian_12.28.12.pdf (99.87 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_JDamian_12.28.12.pdf (99.87 KB) - PDF
TakeCare's Reply Brief Re Motion to Dismiss Procurement Appeal
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 TakeCare Reply Brief 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_TakeCare_Reply_Brief.pdf (690.46 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_TakeCare_Reply_Brief.pdf (690.46 KB) - PDF
Declaration of Service - C Graniel
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Declaration of Service CGraniel 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_CGraniel.pdf (92.62 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Declaration_of_Service_CGraniel.pdf (92.62 KB) - PDF
Order Granting Request Continuance Hearing
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Order Granting Request Continuance Hearing 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Order_Granting_Request_Continuance_Hearing.pdf (158 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Order_Granting_Request_Continuance_Hearing.pdf (158 KB) - PDF
Joint Order for Continuance
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Joint Order for Continuance 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Joint_Order_for_Continuance.pdf (169.21 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Joint_Order_for_Continuance.pdf (169.21 KB) - PDF
Order Denying Request for Continuance
https://mail.opaguam.org 12-013 Order Denying Request for Continuance 0.pdf
PDF icon Download 12-013_Order_Denying_Request_for_Continuance.pdf (167 KB)
PDF icon Download 12-013_Order_Denying_Request_for_Continuance.pdf (167 KB) - PDF


The Procurement Flow Chart is in progress. Please check back shortly.​

OPA Mobile App

  • app-store
  • play-store
 

Highlights…

  • The is an official App from the Office of Public Accountability.
  • The App is FREE.
  • There are no Ads or third party content in the App.
  • The App works across iOS and Android devices. It is available for download directly from the Apple App Store, Google Play, or the OPA website: www.opaguam.org .
  • The App not only works on mobile smartphones, but also works on iOS and Android tablets. This provides greater mobility of information.
  • The App is “light”, which means, once installed and opened, the App provides you with access to thousands of official documents, without using up much of your devices data or storage space. Note, the App requires WiFi or Data (internet connectivity) to operate.
  • The search functionality and numerous filters in the App makes it easy to search the vast library of documents, reports, and more which OPA has released over many years. Content across the App is well organized and easy to find.
  • The App makes these key items available with a few taps for the entire Government of Guam: Performance Audits, Financial Audits, Citizen-Centric Reports, Boards and Commissions Meetings Records, and Procurement Appeals status.
  • The App includes a “hotline” allowing citizens to report concerns or inappropriate activity in the Government.
  • Those who install the App would be able to receive Push Notification Messages from OPA, such as each time an audit is released. OPA will only send important messages occasionally.